We're reader-supported. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission. Learn more

Our Misfits Market Review

Pin

TL;DR
1. We love saving food and we also managed to cut our grocery bill in half – need we say more? 🤑🤑🤑
2. Organic produce and high-quality groceries that you’d normally pay premium prices for.
3. Sustainability for the win: fight the food waste crisis and do some good 🥰🥰
4. Glowing reviews from thousands of customers! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
5. Misfit Market works with The Barrio Fridge to stock fridges around New York feeding underserved communities! 🤗🤗🤗

We’re all becoming increasingly aware of how our diets affect our health. However, with processed junk food being so easy to find, eating healthily can take quite a bit of effort.

These chemical and sugar-filled foods are generally much cheaper than fruits and vegetables as well, making them a much more affordable option for many families.

So, how do you get more fruits and vegetables into your diet and improve your overall well-being without making a special trip to a health food store or breaking the bank? The solution is simple – purchase a Misfits Market subscription. 

Misfits Market delivers affordable. healthy, nutritious food straight to your door. What’s more, the fruits and vegetables included in their boxes are those that don’t look “perfect” enough for grocery stores and, while being absolutely fine to eat, would usually be discarded.

This means you’ll be doing your bit for the planet by reducing food waste as well. It’s a win-win situation!

If you’ve been thinking about purchasing a subscription to Misfits Market for a while and you’re still not certain it’s the best choice for you, you’ve come to the right place! Below, we’ll take an in-depth look at everything Misfits Market has to offer.

We’ll explore prices, how the service works, and those all-important customer reviews!

What is Misfits Market?

Let’s start by taking a look at what Misfits Market actually does. To put it simply, they deliver organic, nutritious food straight to your front door, taking the effort and expense out of having to source it yourself.

The name ‘Misfits’ comes from the fact that all of their fruits and vegetables are what’s known as “imperfect produce”. This is stuff that would usually be deemed too ugly or unappealing to make it to a grocery store and, instead, would be sent to a landfill.

This practice adds a huge annual figure to food waste statistics and, by choosing to sell them instead, Misfits Market is helping to bring this figure way down. 

As if that wasn’t enough of an incentive, a box full of delicious organic produce from Misfits Market costs around 40% less than the prices you’d pay at a grocery store.

So, not only are you helping to save the planet, you’re keeping a few extra dollars in your pocket!

Why you should trust us?

Our team has spent over 15 hours extensively testing and researching the best wellness products, including Misfit Market. Our goal is to find the best brands who care about your well-being and help people live better lives. We evaluate supplements based on their adherence to quality, and their latest medical evidence.

We often ask ourselves a simple question: would we buy the product for ourselves and recommend it to our family and friends? This review is medically reviewed and thoroughly vetted by Amy Bells, our in-house dietian nutritionist, wellness expert and product tester herself!

How we tested Misfits Market

With costs always rising, I was excited to try a new way of saving some money on my groceries! 🤩 Misfits Market offering discounted produce sounded like the perfect idea, so I jumped on the subscription bandwagon and eagerly awaited my first box. 

I got the Value box, which claimed to contain between 11 and 14 best selling items for $35. Sounds great, right? 

When my box came in, I had received: 

  • Blueberries
  • Curly kale
  • English cucumbers
  • Yellow nectarines
  • Avocados 
  • Raspberry flavored dark chocolate
  • Almond milk
  • Garlic and herb organic pasta sauce
  • Zucchini
  • Gala apples
  • Pita flatbread
  • Red Hot Blues tortilla chips.

That’s a lot of food for $35! Not only that, but I also received a bill stating that I had saved $18 on my box should I have purchased all of this food from a grocery store. 🤩

All of the fresh produce was in great condition, with plenty of shelf life so that I didn’t have to rush using everything straight away. 

You might be wondering whether I was actually able to make any meals from my box. Just call me a chef! 👩‍🍳 I made zucchini noodles with pasta sauce and avocado on the side. It was delicious, if I do say so myself! 😁

Of course, that is only one meal able to be made from the weekly box. It’s not going to completely replace my trips to the supermarket. 

However, Misfits Market never claimed to cut out your weekly grocery store run. Instead, it helps to replace the most expensive ingredients for cheaper alternatives. You’re still saving money with Misfits Market as you won’t have to pay more for all of these ingredients at the grocery store. 🤑

Speaking of cheaper prices, I didn’t find anything wrong with the appearance of my produce. Sure, the zucchini and cucumbers weren’t the straightest I’ve ever seen, but they still tasted delicious! 😋

The History of Misfits Market

Pin

Abhi Ramesh founded Misfits Market in 2018 after a visit to a small apple farm in Pennsylvania. It’s during this visit that he discovered how much food goes to waste, simply because the apples didn’t look 100% perfect.

This visit also made him wonder what happens to imperfect produce on large-scale farms.

After discovering that global food waste generates an unbelievable 3.3billion tons of carbon dioxide every year, the idea for Misfits Market was formed.

Cut to a few years later and Misfits Market has received high praise from several publications including Forbes, News Day, Huffington Post, and Healthline.

It also has a dedicated social media following with 289,000 Instagram followers and 230,000 Facebook fans. 

Part of the reason for this high praise is the fact that they are making organic food much more affordable, costing around 40% less than the organic fruits and vegetables you’d find in grocery stores.

Their produce is also non-GMO and is mainly sourced from within America.

Subscription Boxes

Misfits Market works on a subscription basis, delivering your organic produce straight to your front door every week. There are two subscriptions to choose from; the Mischief Box and the Madness Box.

Each of these is designed to cater to smaller or larger families and, as such, contains a different amount of produce. 

The Misfits Market Mischief Box is designed for solo diners or couples and contains 12 types of fruits and vegetables. There are also 1-2 portions of each type of fruit and vegetable. 

The Misfits Market Madness Box is designed for families of around 3-4 people and contains 14 different types of produce. There are 3-4 portions of each type. 

Whichever size of box you need, one thing remains the same for each of them – they contain a variety of seasonal items. This means that the produce you’re receiving is super-fresh and, unlike some grocery store produce, hasn’t been stored for months. 

There’s no need to worry about receiving produce that you won’t like either, as you have the option to build your own box. So, if you simply can’t bear the idea of eating beets, you can add them to your dislikes list and you’ll never receive any. 

All of your produce arrives in environmentally-friendly packaging that can be recycled or composted. During the summer months, it may also come with an eco-friendly ice pack that helps manage fluctuations in temperature and keeps your produce fresh.

This ice pack is also completely recyclable. 

Another fantastic thing about Misfits Market is that you’re able to skip, pause, or cancel your box whenever you want. This means that you don’t have to worry about coming home to a box of rotting vegetables when you get back from vacation!

There aren’t any fees for skipping or canceling your box either. 

Sounds pretty good, right? But are there any downsides to getting a box from Misfits Market?

The only thing we would consider a negative is the fact that you aren’t able to order a one-off box. If you want to try Misfits Market, you’ll need to purchase a subscription.

However, since you’re able to cancel without paying any fees, there’s no risk of losing any money if you decide it’s not the right choice for you. 

We should also note that you cannot cancel an order that has already been paid for. If you need to pause, skip, or cancel, you need to do it before 8 PM EST on the day before your usual billing date. 

What Seasonal Produce Does a Misfits Market Box Contain?

Pin

Since Misfits Market delivers seasonal produce, the fruits and vegetables you’ll receive will differ from month to month.

Here are just a few examples of the produce you can expect to receive at certain times of the year:

Spring & Summer

  • Seasonal Berries
  • Asparagus
  • Rhubarb
  • Eggplant
  • Beets
  • Carrots 
  • Broad Beans
  • Spring Greens
  • Garlic
  • Fennel
  • Lettuce
  • Peppers
  • Tomatoes

Fall & Winter

  • Apples
  • Potatoes
  • Cabbage
  • Broccoli
  • Cranberries
  • Pears
  • Mushrooms
  • Parsnips
  • Squash
  • Pumpkin
  • Swiss Chard
  • Celeriac

Again, you are able to customize your box to suit your tastes. This means that you’ll never receive fruits and vegetables that you don’t like. Instead, you’ll end up with a few extra portions of your favorites!

Discounted Groceries

As well as sending fresh, organic produce straight to your door, Misfits Market gives you the option to supplement your box with discounted groceries. This includes items such as cooking oils, pet foods, and tinned goods. 

Just like their fresh produce, these essential groceries are cheaper than you’d pay in a grocery store as well. This gives you the opportunity to save even more money and, you never know, you might be able to avoid a trip to the grocery store altogether!

Misfits Market: The Cost

You might think that getting organic produce delivered straight to your door is an expensive luxury that only a few people can afford. This was once the case, but Misfits Market has changed that!

Their organic produce also costs around 40% less than grocery stores.

So, just So, just how much can you expect to pay for a Misfits Market subscription? It all depends on the box you choose. Here are the numbers:

  • The Mischief Box – $22 per week
  • The Madness Box – $35 per week

You have the option to be billed either weekly or biweekly depending on your preference, making it a much more manageable option for some people.

And, as we’ve explained a little earlier, you also have the option to skip, pause, or cancel your subscription at any time without paying any penalty fees.

Misfits Market: Customer Reviews

Whenever you’re looking into any product or subscription service, it’s a good idea to look at what people that have previously purchased think.

And, as far as we can see from scouring through hundreds of customer reviews, Misfits Market has overall positive feedback. 

People loved that they were able to get fresh, organic produce for a fraction of the price they’d pay for it in stores. They also really liked the fact that it was delivered straight to their door, freeing up time to do some jobs around the house or focus on self-care. 

Previous Misfits Market customers also commented on how varied the produce is compared to some food subscription services they’d used before. What’s more, they also loved knowing that they were helping to reduce food waste.

Finally, there is a lot of good feedback regarding Misfits Market’s customizable options. This isn’t only ideal for picky eaters but makes it much easier for anybody with certain allergies to control what they’re eating more efficiently. 

It’s not all good, though. There is the occasional negative review regarding delivery times and boxes turning up much later than expected. However, for the most part, the fault here lies with the courier and not with Misfits Market. 

Misfits Market: Pros & Cons

As you can see from their overall positive reviews, many customers are more than happy with the service Misfits Market provides. However, if you’re still not quite sure if they’re the right choice for you, let’s break things down into even simpler terms.

Below, you’ll find a list of pros and cons that will help you make your decision. 

Pros:

  • Organic, non-GMO produce – super healthy food that hasn’t been chemically treated while being grown
  • Reduces food waste – helps lower carbon emissions by selling “imperfect produce” that would usually end up being sent to landfills or composted
  • Affordable – costs around 40% less than grocery stores on average
  • Environmentally-friendly packaging – can be recycled or composted
  • Easy to manage – you can pause, skip, or cancel your subscription at any time
  • Customizable boxes – no risk of receiving products that you don’t like

Cons:

  • Occasional delivery issues – some customers found that their deliveries were later than they expected

Misfit Market vs Imperfect Foods – what sets Misfit Market apart from Imperfect Foods

Imperfect Foods is another popular food subscription box that ships your imperfect produce for a cheaper price. But which is best between them and Misfits Market? 🤨

Overall, both Misfits Market and Imperfect Foods seem to be quite similar. They both upcycle organic produce and package in sustainable packaging. They both offer a cheaper price than the grocery stores. 🤑

You can also alter your subscription with both companies by skipping or pausing it. 

However, Misfits Market requires a $30 minimum spend for your orders, while Imperfect Foods doesn’t have a minimum spend. 

One thing I did like is that Misfits Market has a flat rate for shipping of $6.99, but Imperfect Foods has a shipping rate depending on your location. This means that you could be paying more for shipping, making the total less value for money. 

I think that both of these subscription options are great if you’re wanting to save some money on the food bill, but Misfits Market has the slight edge with better shipping rates and more useful products. 🤗

Is Misfits Market Worth the Money?

This is the million-dollar question! If you’re looking for an affordable way of feeding yourself and your family with healthy, organic produce, there’s no doubt that Misfits Market is worth the money.

In fact, their pricing is around 40% less than you’d pay at a grocery store!

What’s more, you’re given the convenience of having your fresh produce delivered straight to our door. You can also supplement it with other essential groceries. This could potentially mean no stressful trips to the grocery store!

The amount of produce you’ll receive is perfect for the number of people you’re feeding, too.

So, not only are you helping to reduce mass food waste by purchasing “imperfect produce”, you’re reducing food waste at home by feeding everybody with the correct portion size. 

If there is one thing that might put you off the idea of purchasing a Misfits Market subscription box, it’s that there are reports of occasional delivery issues.

These are few and far between though and, in the instances where this problem has been reported, the customer service team resolved the issue to the customer’s satisfaction. 

How Do You Sign Up for Misfits Market?

It couldn’t be easier to sign up for Misfits Market. Simply head over to their website and follow these instructions:

  1. Navigate to the top right-hand corner of the page and click on “Get Started”. 
  2. Enter your email address and zip code into the appropriate fields. 
  3. Select the plan that best fits your needs, how often you want to receive a delivery, and on what date you’d like to receive it. 
  4. Enter your payment and shipping information.
  5. Customize your box and complete your purchase.

It’s really that easy! The Misfits Market website is user-friendly and easy to navigate as well, so there’s very little chance of you getting lost as you look through produce and select any supplemental groceries. 

Discounts & Promotions

Even though Misfits Market costs around 40% less than organic produce purchased from a grocery store, it’s always nice to save a few extra bucks wherever you can! So, what discounts and promotions are on offer?

Firstly, if you sign up to Misfit Market’s mailing list, you’ll be first to know about any available discount codes and coupons. Some of these are exclusive to new customers, so this is definitely worth doing and keeping an eye out for before you purchase your first box.

Misfits Market also offers a referral program. Recommend any family or friends with your personal code and you’ll receive $10 off a future order. They’ll also receive $10 off their first order. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Where does Misfits Market deliver?

Misfits Market currently delivers to all zip codes in the following states:

  • Pennsylvania
  • New York
  • New Jersey
  • Connecticut 
  • Delaware
  • Massachusetts
  • Vermont
  • New Hampshire
  • Rhode Island
  • Maine
  • Ohio
  • West Virginia
  • Washington D.C.
  • Virginia
  • Maryland
  • North Carolina
  • South Carolina
  • Illinois
  • Indiana
  • Kentucky
  • Alabama
  • Georgia
  • Florida
  • Tennessee
  • Texas
  • Mississippi
  • Missouri
  • Louisiana
  • Arkansas
  • Michigan
  • Wisconsin
  • Minnesota
  • Iowa
  • Utah
  • Idaho
  • Colorado
  • Kansas
  • Nevada
  • Washington
  • Oregon

If your state isn’t on this list, Misfits Market currently doesn’t deliver. However, you can join their waiting list and they’ll let you know as soon as they start delivering in your area.

Where is Misfits Market based?

Although Misfits Market was founded in Pennsylvania, it’s headquarters are located in New Jersey. There are also several locations around the United States where their produce is sorted, assembled, and shipped from.

What comes in Misfits Market box?

This ultimately depends on the type of box you’ve chosen. You have two options; the Mischief Box and the Madness Box.

Each of these contains a different number of seasonal, organic fruits and vegetables that are perfectly portioned for the number of people the box is intended to feed. You also have the option to supplement your box with discounted grocery items.

Is Misfits Market packaging recyclable?

Yes, it is! All of Misfits Market packaging can be curbside recycled or added to your compost heap. In the summer months, your box may contain an eco-ice pack to help keep your produce fresh in the hot temperatures. This can also be curbside recycled.

Can I cancel my Misfits Market subscription?

It’s quite easy to cancel your Misfits Market subscription. Simply head to your account and click the ‘Manage Subscriptions’ option.

Scroll to the bottom of the page, select ‘Cancel’, and you’re all done. You can also skip and pause your subscription through the ‘Manage Subscriptions’ menu.

Can I change my Misfits Market delivery day?

Absolutely! Simply head to the ‘Manage Subscriptions’ section on the Misfits Market website. Here, you’ll be able to change your preferred delivery day and how frequently you receive deliveries.

How much are Misfits Market’s shipping costs?

Each Misfits Market box comes with a $5.50 shipping fee. Boxes are shipped from Monday to Sunday and will arrive on the date you’ve chosen when setting up your account.

You’ll also receive a text message letting you know when your order has shipped, and you can track your delivery through your Misfits Market account.

How can I return something to Misfits Market?

Unfortunately, Misfits Market doesn’t currently accept any returns, and all of their sales are final and non-refundable.

In the unlikely event of something going wrong with your box, you are urged to contact Misfit’s Market customer service team within five days of receiving your order.

Upon doing this, they will review the issue and offer a resolution from there.

Can I choose what produce I receive in a Misfits Market box?

Yes, you are able to customize your box to suit your specific tastes. As soon as the weekly shopping window opens, you can make your produce picks from the assortment of fruits and vegetables on offer.

Anything that you don’t like won’t be added to your box.

What type of produce does Misfits Market offer?

Misfits Market offers seasonal produce, so the fruits and vegetables that you can choose from will change throughout the year.

For example, during fall and winter you can expect to receive produce such as apples, kale, chard, cabbage, sweet potatoes, and squash, all of which are in season during these months.

You’re also able to add some discounted grocery items to your box all year round.

Is all of Misfits Market’s produce organic?

The majority of produce on offer from Misfits Market is certified organic and non-GMO, and all organic produce is clearly indicated on the website.

However, there are occasions where conventionally grown produce is sent out in boxes to stop it from going to food waste.

Where does Misfits Market source their produce from?

Most of Misfits Market’s organic produce is sourced from hand-picked farms and food hubs across America. There are instances where some produce is rescued from other countries.

They also source cooking supplies and pantry staples from within America and from other sustainable sources. 

Does Misfits Market deliver to P.O boxes?

As Misfits Market sells perishable produce, they are unable to deliver to P.O boxes. However, if you would like to purchase a Misfits Market box but you’re unable to receive delivery due to being away from home, you do have the option to deliver to an alternative address (such as a friend or neighbor).

You may also like

Athletic Greens – high-performance supplement for nutrition and gut health
Ritual Vitamins – vegan essential vitamins for women
Blendjet – next-generation, portable, cult-favorite blender

Leave a Comment